I was fixing the wrong things.
I’d love to report that I edited Deliberately Lost with the cool precision of a professional. What actually happened is that I spent an embarrassing amount of time agonizing over commas in chapters that needed to be merged, moved, or set on fire.
Blame academia. I’m a recovering academic, so my first reflex in revision is to tighten, cite, and defend every choice to a committee that doesn’t exist. That’s great for a dissertation. On a novel, it means you can lovingly polish a paragraph that has no business being in the book.
For anyone just joining us: Deliberately Lost is a sapphic paranormal romance about Maxine, a small-town librarian who hasn’t finished a manuscript in six years and runs a blog that makes her small life sound enormous. Then she buys a one-way ticket and retraces her grandmother’s 1952 trip across Europe, and along the way she collects a ghost in Scotland, a very strange bookshop, and a centuries-old vampire named Lena on a night train. My edit started at 27 chapters, ballooned to 33, then got hacked back into a prologue plus 31, about 82,000 words. Somewhere in the middle I figured out what the book was actually about, which the first draft had failed to mention.
I’m keeping spoilers to a minimum, so nobody has to yell at me in the comments.
What I’ve learned about writing so far
I’ve been at this a while, and these are the lessons that actually stuck. Each one stuck because it cost me something.
Your first draft is a sneaky little thing, because its real job is to tell you what the book is. Maxine and Lena grew out of an earlier story and changed a lot before landing here. The night-train cold open that now starts the book showed up almost last. So write the messy thing, then edit like you had the plan all along. Nobody has to know.
Decide what you’re promising the reader, then go check that you delivered. I wanted this one to be a romance first, and in the draft I was editing, the love interest didn’t wander in until chapter 10. Anyone who came for the love story would have been checking their watch.
Voices matter more than descriptions. If you can swap two characters’ lines and nobody notices, one of them isn’t finished.
Let someone else hear it. My wife and I did a read-aloud pass, and she pointed out that I had never actually said what Maxine looks like. I’d been living in her head so long that I assumed everyone could see her. They could not.
And your habits are invisible to you, because you’re the one who wrote them. Everybody has pet words. Ctrl+F does not care about your feelings, which is exactly what you want from it.
How the edit actually went
There was no master plan. The passes sorted themselves out as I went, but looking back, the order is worth stealing. Each pass gets exactly one question, and I try very hard not to answer any other question while I’m in it. (I don’t always succeed. Typos are extremely distracting.)
First came structure. Where’s the plot climax, where’s the emotional climax, and are they standing in the same room? Mine weren’t. I lined them up and made the main character’s big refusal cost her something real, and I didn’t touch a single sentence while doing it. That was harder than it sounds.
Second was pacing and promise. I trimmed the first eleven chapters, merged the two Rome chapters, merged the two Highlands chapters, and split one bloated chapter into three. I added the prologue so the romance shows up on page one, and slipped a little note of waiting into each early adventure so the reader can feel something coming.
Third, finally, sentences. By then a bunch of the ones I would have spent an afternoon on had been cut along with the scenes they lived in, which is the most satisfying way I know to get out of work.
Fourth was voice. One character at a time, I read only their dialogue, start to finish, and asked whether it sounded like one person. It’s a strange way to read a book and I recommend it.
Fifth was continuity: names, dates, places, who knows what and when. This is where I learned that a town in my book has no train station, and that I had cheerfully given it one.
Sixth was reading aloud, with another human in the room. Your ear catches rhythm problems and missing information that your eyes skate right past.
Last came the slow final pass. I paused everything else, posting included, and crawled through the manuscript. By then I wasn’t hunting for big problems. I was just making sure the book felt like itself from the first line to the last.
What to watch for (so you can skip my mistakes)
Climaxes that don’t match
A book usually has a plot climax, the thing that happens, and an emotional one, the moment the character changes. If they show up in different places, readers feel a vague letdown and can’t tell you why. Check where yours sit. Then ask what the big choice costs your character. If the answer is nothing, it’s not much of a choice.
Big moments that don’t happen on the page
If the whole book hinges on a confession, a betrayal, or a decision, put it in a scene with a before and an after. My blog confession now lands as an actual event the reader watches, with consequences, instead of something that gets mentioned in passing.
Crowded rooms
I had a whole chorus of characters weighing in on the same question. It turns out a committee is not a character. I cut it to four, and when your scene needs a crowd, ask which four the reader would actually miss.
Facts the story leans on
There are two ways to get this wrong. One is the plain error, like my phantom train station. The other is a fact the ending depends on that the reader hasn’t been told yet. In my case, the grandmother’s 1952 trip to Yugoslavia needed to be on the page earlier. Keep a one-page cheat sheet of settings, dates, and rules, then for every fact your ending uses, go find the first place the reader learns it. If you can’t find it, that’s your answer.
A protagonist nobody can see
Spend months in a character’s head and you forget to mention what she looks like. Maxine’s fix took a few lines in chapter one: tall enough to reach the top shelf without the step stool, a low dark ponytail she’s worn since college, a scatter of freckles. That’s it. Readers just need something to hold onto.
Voices that blur
Cover up the speaker tags and see if you can still tell who’s talking. Deb in my book is telegraphic: she doesn’t ask things, she files them. Maxine’s mother can turn a passing mention of a woman named Bethany into a monologue about the Piggly Wiggly and a coupon for chicken thighs. Lena doesn’t use contractions, ever, and says things like “I contain very few undramatic answers, I am afraid.” (She’s three centuries old. She’s earned it.) A rule like that only works if it holds everywhere, so even after the voice pass I search for stray apostrophes in her lines. Lena does not say “I’ll.”
Your own pet words
I searched one draft for my favorites and found “properly” sixty times, “not quite” twenty-six, and “oddly” fifteen. Apparently everyone in this book does things properly, and also oddly, and also not quite. None of those are bad words. But once a reader spots one three times, they start seeing it everywhere, like a tune you can’t unhear. Search for yours, keep the ones doing real work, and bury the rest.
A promise that shows up late
If the central relationship doesn’t appear until a third of the way in, readers who came for it will feel the wait. I wanted Lena earlier, but I also wanted Maxine to have her adventures first, and moving the meeting would have wrecked that. So I added a prologue instead. When two good fixes fight each other, there’s often a third one hiding.
The name on the cover
This book started out hotter than Harlo Malone’s usual. I brought it back to his standard sensual fade to black. Know what each of your names promises, and edit toward it on purpose.
That’s the lot
Structure first, sentences last, other people’s ears somewhere in the middle, and Ctrl+F for your own bad habits. That’s the whole system, such as it is.
What’s the thing you always find in your own edits? Tell me in the comments. I’d like to know I’m not the only one with a word that shows up sixty times.
Leave a Reply